Skip to content

Why the planning debate still matters today

Ben Elliott / Unsplash
Shaun Spiers
By Shaun Spiers
17th November 2026

In our centenary year we’ve been reflecting on what we can learn from our achievements over the years. Shaun Spiers draws on 18 years as our Chief Executive to explore the lessons of past planning battles. He makes the case for a stronger planning system that can deliver much-needed homes as well as a thriving countryside.

I enjoyed Andrew Purkis’s piece on how CPRE became the modern, campaigning organisation it now is. I became chief executive in 1999, eight years after Andrew’s stint, and stayed for 18 years – a long time, but not a patch on Sir Herbert Griffin’s 39 years.

'As ever, CPRE was fighting a rearguard action against countryside loss. This is inevitable: as population and prosperity increase, countryside will be lost. The question is, how much and what can be gained; what can be made more beautiful or richer in nature?'

In my time, CPRE ran plenty of positive campaigns on tranquillity, night skies, local foods, countryside character and much else. We won a new National Park in the South Downs incorporating the Western Weald (Hilary Benn, the environment secretary, presented CPRE’s president, Bill Bryson, with a map of the new park with a handwritten note, ‘this would not have happened without you’). We set out a positive, even inspiring 2026 vision for the countryside, looking forward to this centenary year.

We also, of course, campaigned against things – litter, roadside advertising, new roads, out of town superstores… Some of these campaigns were successful, some are never likely to be won fully (driving from Kent to Rutland recently, I wondered if CPRE might have another go at ugly roadside hoardings).

But in retrospect, the years 1999 to 2017 were dominated by two issues: housing and, closely linked, the slow erosion of political support for a strong, democratic planning system. (Countryside battles in my time were not, of course, limited to housing. There were plenty of fights over wind farms, for instance, which I have written about elsewhere.)

When I joined CPRE, planning was in. Conservative ministers had championed the planning system as an important tool for environmental and social improvement and John Prescott, loathed though he was by many in the shires, followed suit.

The government’s Urban Task Force, chaired by Richard Rogers, championed good design, brownfield development, higher densities and much else that CPRE welcomed. Tony Burton, CPRE’s policy director, was a member of the task force, as was Martin Crookston, later a CPRE trustee. The government introduced ambitious planning guidance in line with the task force recommendations. In 2003, it designated four growth areas to focus development and prevent sprawl.

Reflecting on my years with CPRE, my biggest regret is that we did not manage to work with Prescott. This was partly his fault. Notoriously thin-skinned, before I arrived he had objected to something CPRE had said or done and banned his ministers from seeing us. Denied meaningful access, and not trying hard enough to get it, we hammered Prescott’s policies rather than working to improve them.

Gradually support for strong planning policies gave way to a familiar pattern: governments set over ambitious housing targets that rely on private sector delivery; the house builders say they can only build with fewer conditions; they get their way (requirements for brownfield development, good design, sustainability and affordability are dropped as ‘unviable’) – and still they fail to build enough new homes.

'In view of all this, it is not surprising that countryside campaigners are often in the trenches crying 'No!'. Much countryside has been saved by bloody-minded campaigners resisting development and I am grateful to them.'

But saying ‘no’ will never be enough. In my 2008 book, How to build houses and save the countryside, still the perfect Christmas present, I set out how CPRE was, in its origin, ‘less anti-development than pro-beauty’. Its 1926 ‘aims and objects’ state: ‘It is not intended that the CPRE shall be a merely negative force. It is part of its policy to promote suitable and harmonious development.’ In The preservation of rural England, CPRE’s foundation text, Patrick Abercrombie wrote: ‘It should be possible for a just balance to be struck between conservation and development: that certain parts must be preserved intact and inviolate but that others can, after suffering a change, bring forth something new but beautiful, provided a conscious effort is made.’

Given the scale of the housing crisis, we now need more conscious effort by both government and campaigners to ‘bring forth something new but beautiful’. The model tested to destruction for most of the last 45 years – weak planning and a dependence on private sector delivery – has failed so spectacularly that a new start should be possible.

The only way to solve the housing crisis is to get serious about social housing and muscular planning, including new settlements and large urban extensions. But to have any chance of community consent for such developments, it will be essential to put good design, public transport, energy efficiency and nature at their heart. The government should embrace this agenda rather than obsessing about undeliverable housing targets. And if it truly wants to succeed, it should work with CPRE to get agreement about what should be built, where.

Explainers

Dive deeper into the topics we care about with our handy explainer guides.